By Derek Soled, Michelle Bayefsky and Rahul Nayak. Early in the Covid-19 outbreak in the United States, President Trump suggested that the cure – closing the American economy and sheltering at home – may be worse than the disease. Although he was criticized for focusing on the economy when so many lives were at stake, […]
Latest articles
Children of COVID-19: Pawns, pathfinders or partners?
By Vic Larcher and Joe Brierley. Countries throughout the world are counting the health and socio-economic costs of the COVID-19 pandemic, including the strategies necessary to contain it. Profound consequences from social isolation are beginning to emerge, and there is an urgency about charting a path to recovery, albeit to a “new normal” that mitigates […]
Autonomy under Lockdown
By Ben Colburn. In my philosophical work I mostly think about the nature and value of personal autonomy. Autonomy consists in an individual deciding for herself what is valuable, and living her life in accordance with that decision. Living an autonomous life means living a life which is valuable for you in your own eyes. […]
The UK Government’s COVID-19 legal strategy is compromising end-of-life ethics and human rights compliance
By Stephen Thomson. End-of-life ethics and the human rights of dying patients and their families are being compromised by the UK Government’s legal and communications response to COVID-19. Despite NHS England’s Visitor Guidance continuing to state that one immediate family member or carer will be permitted to visit a patient who is receiving end-of-life care, […]
Lives vs equity – analysing the dilemma in the COVID-19 response
By Neil Pickering An ethical tension that COVID-19 highlights is between saving lives and acting equitably. Bluntly, in the current circumstances, it may be that any weight given to equity will potentially cost lives. This need not always be the case, of course. The two can both be realised at one and the same time […]
The many meanings of “stay safe” in a pandemic: Sympathy, duty, and threat
By David Shaw. You’re out for a walk, your daily exercise since the pandemic began. You bump into someone you know (metaphorically speaking), exchange a few words about life under lockdown from the other side of the road, and then wish them well before setting off again. Chances are you wish them well with the […]
Compulsory treatment or vaccination versus quarantine
By Thomas Douglas, Jonathan Pugh and Lisa Forsberg. Governments worldwide have responded to the Covid-19 pandemic with sweeping constraints on freedom of movement, including various forms of isolation, quarantine, and ‘lockdown’. Governments have also introduced new legal instruments to guarantee the lawfulness of their measures. In the UK, the Coronavirus Act 2020 gives the government […]
Experiment on identical siblings separated at birth: Ethical implications for researchers, universities and archives today
By Adam Kelmenson, MS & Robert Klitzman, MD The 2018 film Three Identical Strangers brought wide media and public attention to a previously little-known 1960’s psychological study. The researchers had secretly separated several sets of twins and one set of triplets into adoptive families, and then studied them for decades without disclosing to the […]
How much certainty is enough? Immunity passports and COVID-19
By Rebecca brown, Julian Savulescu, Bridget Williams and Dominic Wilkinson. There is significant debate about whether or not ‘immunity passports’ are a viable tool to use in responding to the current COVID-19 pandemic. Much of this has focused on the lack of a sufficiently reliable antibody test, and uncertainty about the immune status of individuals […]
PPE may protect us, but it harms the sweatshop workers who make it
Arianne Shahvisi and Mei Trueba. One of the greatest controversies of the UK coronavirus crisis is the shortage of PPE for NHS workers. Yet most PPE is made in sweatshops, and its production endangers the health of those who make it. Ironically, workers who produce personal protective equipment for others invariably have inadequate protection themselves. […]