You don't need to be signed in to read BMJ Group Blogs, but you can register here to receive updates about other BMJ Group products and services via our Group site.

John Clark on engaging leadership: hope for the future lies with a new breed of doctors

26 Apr, 12 | by BMJ

With a few exceptions, medical students have little, if any, training in management, leadership, and service improvement. Yet from the moment they graduate, doctors require a range of such competencies, which become more important as they progress to become consultants and general practitioners.

Early exposure to management and leadership should provide the foundation for an NHS in which doctors appreciate their responsibilities to others within the multi-professional team, the organisation, and local health community, as well as to their patients and themselves.

The joint “Enhancing Engagement in Medical Leadership” project led by the NHS Institute for Innovation and Improvement and The Academy of Medical Royal Colleges, after wide consultation, has developed a Medical Leadership Competency Framework (MLCF) that describes the key competencies required by medical students, postgraduate doctors, and those in continuing practice. The framework has been adopted by the General Medical Council (GMC) and all the Royal Colleges and is now slowly but surely influencing undergraduate and postgraduate specialty training. It has also been accepted by all clinical professions and forms the basis of the new NHS Leadership Framework.

The new Faculty of Medical Leadership and Management (FMLM) has created an opportunity to promote the advancement of medical leadership, management, and quality improvement at all stages of a doctor’s training and career. It has an important role to spread good practice and to support initiatives that will make the incorporation of the agreed competencies into curricula and experiences both stimulating and relevant.

As well as a growing recognition that junior doctors need to develop management and leadership skills, many medical students and postgraduate trainee doctors are increasingly being attracted to the study and application of service improvement methodologies. A study by Gilbert et al (2012) concluded that doctors in training have a desire and ability to contribute to improvement in the NHS but do not perceive their working environment as receptive to their skills. Junior doctors who attend leadership training reported higher levels of desire and ability to express these skills. The study suggests that junior doctors are an untapped NHS resource and that they and their organisations would benefit from more formalised provision of training in leadership.

There are already some exciting initiatives that support junior doctors to lead improvement, such as the Darzi Clinical Fellowship programme (supported by The King’s Fund) and the NHS Medical Director’s Clinical Fellows Scheme (run by the FMLM). There are also a number of regional programmes, including those led by the North West Deanery and the Kent, Surrey, and Sussex Deanery, which link doctors and managers in their development programmes.

To encourage further adoption of the medical leadership movement, it is important to share which initiatives are being incorporated into undergraduate and postgraduate training, and to analyse and assess the impact of the different approaches.

Our next leadership and management review, due on 23 May, will explore the theme of “engaging leadership.” It will examine the growing evidence that securing greater engagement of staff generally—and doctors in particular—in leadership leads to a higher quality of care and greater productivity.

We support the development of clinicians at all stages in their careers—find out more about our leadership development work.

John Clark is a senior fellow, leadership development at the King’s Fund.

This blog also appears on the King’s Fund website at http://www.kingsfund.org.uk/blog/

By submitting your comment you agree to adhere to these terms and conditions
  • http://www.pmhut.com/ PM Hut

    Hi John,

    I totally agree with you – a doctor is one of those professions where having leadership is a must. After all, any doctor has many followers including trainees, nurses, etc… and must deal with a lot of people everyday!

    I think doctors should probably focus more on the leadership aspect to enhance their careers.

  • Andrew

     Could not resist replying to this  …  I am concerned that the concept of Leadership is misplaced as we strive for more sophisticated interactions with our professional colleagues. Trainees need mentoring; nurses do not follow doctors but work with them as part of a team; professional allied to medicine have experts in a spectrum of fields who advise and consult. The days of Sir Lancelot Sprat are long over and indeed the Medical Profession has been emasculated through a series of reforms that have left it confused, weak and full of self-doubt. To spring Leadership into the innocent minds of medical students is perhaps a recipe for disaster.  Unless of course it is put in the real context of a battle for Leadership which is a political battle played on the wastelands of the Modern NHS. What I do suggest is that new doctors learn some of the tricks of the trade, the language of communication and strategies for engaging in battle with the administrators and the medical politicians: instead of doing an intercalated Medical Science degree to an MBA. Please note you do NOT have to have leadership skills to deal effectively with a lot of people every day   …  but you do need skills of some sort! Look at all those people in the service industries and look at the archetypal power lord in any institution – the car park attendant. A good one can be very effective in control and allocation of precious resources; can spread happiness in the good days but can bring stubborn misery on the bad days. Perhaps it is a different form of leadership!

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
BMJ blogs homepage

BMJ.com

Helping doctors make better decisions. Visit site



Creative Comms logo

Latest from BMJ.com

Latest from BMJ.com

Latest from BMJ.com podcasts

Latest from BMJ.com podcasts

Blogs linking here

Blogs linking here