Julian Sheather: Unrest

julian_sheatherThe award-winning cinema documentary Unrest explores the stories of people living with ME/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. Ahead of its UK theatrical release on 20 October, Julian Sheather, Specialist Adviser, Ethics and Human Rights at the BMA, says the film raises important issues for the medical community.

What do we mean by illness? What is a disease? How do we really know that another human being is suffering? What is the difference between mental and physical pain? And if there is a difference, does it matter?

For most of us these are academic questions. For Jennifer Brea, they are the stuff of life. In her mid-twenties she was felled by a mysterious illness. About to marry, studying for her PhD at Harvard, and poised, just as her childhood self had instructed her, “to swallow the world,” she was laid low by a succession of viral infections. And then came near catatonia. She fell into a condition of agonized, almost mitochondrial, depletion. She slid away into a persistent, room-bound twilight. Light was painful. To move she had to haul herself, elbow by elbow across the floor. Her life got up and left her.

She ran the predictable gauntlet of specialists: bemused endocrinologists, rheumatologists, cardiologists and psychiatrists. There were investigations, hypotheses, bewilderments. Some said it was psychogenic, the late dark flower of an early trauma (recall that before brain scans multiple sclerosis was labelled psychogenic and dubbed hysterical paralysis.) Some said it was her immune system. Others that it was dehydration or the stress of study.

Then she turned to the internet. And found a virtual continent of fellow-sufferers. People hidden for decades, some permanently bedridden, some almost foetal with pain. Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, Myalgic Encephalomyelitis—call it what you will, here was a dispersed pandemic of unplumbed suffering.

Unrest is the film Jennifer Brea made about her condition. It is not an easy watch. She does not pull her punches. It takes us into the dark folds of a cruelly disabling condition. It is a defiant film though—not least because she makes it in dogged defiance of her condition. And it provokes ceaseless questions.

One that stayed with me is the long squabble between psychological and physical etiology. I get that to treat a condition it helps to know its cause. But what I don’t get is the insinuation—not from the filmmaker, but from some of the commentators—that if it is mental rather than physical, choice is involved. The phrase “it’s all in the mind” suggests that all we need do is change it. Change our mind and the problem dissolves. But such a view of mental phenomena is puerile. Our minds are not sovereign over themselves in these things. And the quicker we ditch that stale and exhausted canard the better.

Unrest also provokes philosophical questions about other minds. Because a devastating condition is not well-captured by current diagnostic possibilities, questions have arisen in the past about its reality. Is this suffering or elaborate malingering? There is a barbed little snapshot of Ricky Gervais in stand-up mode, riffing on ME: wouldn’t we all like time off work? The joke clangs like a stone in a dustbin. Truth is the only way we know another is suffering is if they tell us. We cannot get unmediated access to the sensations of others. It is the suffering that counts. There is a lesson for medicine here.

Unrest is heroic filmmaking. It takes a mysterious, stigmatized and invisible disorder and brings the condition and its sufferers into clear light. It is a tribute to the filmmaker and her extraordinary husband. And also a reminder, if we need it, that the world of human suffering has not been mapped in its entirety by medicine.

Julian Sheather is ethics manager, BMA. The views he expresses in his opinion pieces are entirely his own.

Unrest is released in UK cinemas on October 20th. For more information, visit www.unrest.film

  • Dianne Mawhood

    excellent writing . thank you from a long term sufferer for clearly articulating th’e wholeness’ of the pain of suffering fom an unrecognised disease

  • Ted Lewis

    “Call it what you will”, eh Julian?

    Call it Chronic Fatigue Syndrome and you wil get psychotherapy.

    Call it Myalgic Encephalomyelitis and you will get no treatment at all.

  • W Douglas Taylor

    I have been an ME sufferer for 34 years. I thought in the beginning that some kind of treatment would become available eventually, although one’s definition of “eventually” has had to change over the years. Incidentally, I was shocked to learn from my GP that at medical college they were taught that there was no such thing as ME.
    Anyway, my pet gripe is the tagging on of CFS to ME. CFS is a merely a term accredited to an undiagnosed condition that could be caused by, say, a heart problem or cancer etc. etc. No wonder, then, that GET is often imposed on ME patients much to their considerable detriment.
    I am really looking forward to seeing the film, and hope that it can be shown at some stage on main-stream TV in order to reach the largest audiences.

  • Is there any mention of Dr. Sarah Myhill’s work in Jennifer Brea’s story?
    http://www.drmyhill.co.uk/wiki/Main_Page

    Surely, she has contacted her for help?