You don't need to be signed in to read BMJ Blogs, but you can register here to receive updates about other BMJ products and services via our site.

Parijaat Vaidya reviews When a mother’s love is not enough

18 Nov, 09 | by BMJ Group

Parijaat VaidyaAs the mother of a severely disabled child and a psychiatrist working with learning disabled children, I was particularly interested in this BBC documentary which highlights the enormous challenges families face in bringing up a child with disabilities.

Presented by Rosa Monckton, mother of a girl with Down’s Syndrome, the documentary shines a light on the lives that families with disabled children live. It makes uncomfortable viewing. We discover just why some carers are driven to desperation where they want to kill their children and be killed as well. There is the story of Rosa herself and her response to the discovery of a disabled daughter, her sense of horror and despair but helped by access to various services that enabled her to be a “mother” and not just a “carer.” We also learn of Cameron, a 17 year old with Asperger’s syndrome who (to me as a psychiatrist appears to also be suffering from Tourette’s Syndrome but) falls between two services (child and adult). There are experiences of other families with single mothers struggling, their non-disabled children becoming the silent victims and the inevitable fears and the lack of answers for their disabled child’s future. The common experience of families with disabled children facing similar emotional problems whatever their social class is also apparent. This doesn’t exclude David Cameron, leader of the Conservative party who appeared to be holding back his tears when recalling his son.

As a carer and a professional, I felt that the documentary strongly portrays how the lack of emotional adjustment, combined with feelings of embarrassment and guilt, can make the burden of care intolerable, plus the social isolation and lack of adequately responsive support services which could sometimes result in desperate mothers ending it all, an outcome which ought to be preventable at all costs in a caring society.

Some additional information on the way families could go about accessing resources within the currently existing legal ,social and healthcare frameworks would have enhanced the the usefulness of this film for isolated carers. Nevertheless, this is a powerfully insightful film for professionals and politicians alike.

Parijaat Vaidya is a specialist registrar in child and adolescent psychiatry at Sheffield Children’s NHS Foundation Trust.

By submitting your comment you agree to adhere to these terms and conditions
  • Les Simpson

    Down Syndrome (and Aspergers) is acompanied by changes in the shape populations of red cells. Such changes reduce the deformability of red cells and impair capillary blood flow.
    I have found that patients with either condition benefit from 4 grams daily of evening primrose oil, which increases the blood levels of prostaglandin.
    I presented my findings at an international meeting on Down Syndrome in Cairns, Australia, but no one was interested. The consensus was that the only significant treatment for Down people was education.
    The Down Syndrome specialists were unwilling to concede that normal tissue function requires normal rates of blood flow.
    Dr.Vaidya should suggest evening primrose oil to parents with Down children – it does no harm and can be very helpful.
    Les Simpson.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
BMJ blogs homepage

The BMJ

Helping doctors make better decisions. Visit site



Creative Comms logo

Latest from The BMJ

Latest from The BMJ

Latest from BMJ podcasts

Latest from BMJ podcasts

Blogs linking here

Blogs linking here