You don't need to be signed in to read BMJ Group Blogs, but you can register here to receive updates about other BMJ Group products and services via our Group site.

Tiago Villanueva: Poverty and hunger in Portugal

7 Feb, 13 | by BMJ Group

Tiago_VillanuevaSome time ago a patient told me that he needed to borrow money from a neighbour to buy a train ticket to come to his appointment at the practice. At the same time, this patient told me about the scarcity of food at home, and how it was a constant struggle to feed his daughter. The shocking thing is that this is happening in Portugal. The daily life of an increasing number of people in Portugal is affected by poverty and hunger, two of the most dramatic consequences of the austerity that has been crippling Portuguese society for the past year and a half. A recent report by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development states that the spending cuts in the health sector in Portugal have been two times larger than those agreed by the “Troika”—the International Monetary Fund, the European Central Bank, and the European Union). The Portuguese Ministry of Health denies this. But, the report adds that Portugal’s spending in the health sector is expected to fall to 5.1% of GDP in 2013, down from over 10% in 2010, and much lower than the average of 7% of GDP for the Eurozone.

There are reports that an increasing number of children go to school without eating breakfast and are being seen in hospital simply for being hungry. This may be hard to believe in a first world country, but it is partly related to the fact that unemployment continues to soar (it has now reached 16.5%), and the number of couples where both individuals are unemployed almost doubled in 2012 compared with 2011. In fact, according to a report by TNS Global, roughly three out of four people in Portugal struggle to have enough money to last for the month and pay their bills.

Some patients who live in households where everyone is unemployed have told me that they have had to move back to their elderly and often ill parents’ homes. It is important to note that unemployment rates would actually be much higher if so many people were not leaving the country to pursue employment opportunities overseas as they are now. It is not surprising that many people who could previously be considered middle class are now beginning to slide below the poverty line and are having to resort for the first time to shelters and soup kitchens. They are being labelled the “embarrassed poor,” as in some cases we’re talking about people who previously had good jobs, a certain social status, and could afford luxuries such as holidays overseas. Many children are being transferred by their parents from private to public schools.

Portugal’s Catholic background has been helpful, as parishes are currently one of the strongest drivers for providing social aid to local communities. I have witnessed this when carrying out home visits and seeing parish staff deliver meals to patients at home. And it goes further. Lisbon’s central mosque, near where I live, provides meals to dozens of non-Muslim people on a number of days every month. Likewise, Portugal’s family oriented culture also remains as one of the most powerful support networks for many deprived patients.

In terms of daily clinical work, more patients than ever are reporting anxious and/or depressive symptoms, particularly among those who are unemployed or at risk of becoming unemployed, and those facing borderline poverty. There is much less demand for sick leave than before, as many patients report being afraid of losing their jobs, even if that means going to work when they are unwell. Moreover, more and more of my time is now taken up writing medical reports requested by foreign employers for patients who are about to leave the country to work abroad. I’ve already done it for all sorts of professions, including healthcare professionals such as nurses and dentists. A hospital in West Suffolk has just recruited 40 Portuguese nurses, and many of Portugal’s “best and brightest” young professionals are simply moving on.

Tiago Villanueva is a locum GP based in Portugal, and a former BMJ Clegg Scholar and editor, Student BMJ.

By submitting your comment you agree to adhere to these terms and conditions
  • Chris

    Having come from Portugal in the late summer where I visited my partners grandparents, I learned too well how much the unemployment and fear of losing jobs is affecting a large proportion of the Portuguese society. One story of a man working 6 days a week 12 hours per day for 400 euro, which in fairness just about covered his rent, was left with 50 euro from the remaining month for food. His fear that if he took a day off to attend a meal with us and the rest of the family, he may not have a job the next day, as competition for jobs was so high, What is still a beautiful country is being plagued by unemployment, lack of proper benefits and a moral stigma that some people don’t want to work, I’ve seen it time after time again, they want jobs, they want a decent wage and they want their country to pull out of this economic downturn. I shall continue to return to Portugal for many years as I love the country.

  • Cristiano van Zeller

    Being a Portuguese FY1 doctor working in London at the moment, having studied all my undergraduate degree in the UK, I am all too sheltered from this reality. The only contact I have had with it has been through the media and reports from family members of mine who have unfortunately been taken ill over the previous 6 years and which have led me to visit them in various institutions around Oporto. It is incredibly distressing for me to hear about these situations. It only makes me more appreciative of the system in place in the UK, despite all its flaws. The NHS provides free medication, free consultations and free inpatient care to anyone, has an extremely efficient NICE which analyses the best treatments and provides clinicians with the most up-to-date evidence based guidelines and free transport for patients to and from clinics and inpatient admissions. It even shocked a family member of mine who was taken ill one day in the UK who, when leaving the Hospital, frantically looked for the “Checkout” or “Pay till” to pay for his 2 day admission for renal calculi, only to be told his 2 hour search had been in vain and would instead have a more considerable car parking charge to take care of. Everytime I hear one of my patients criticise the NHS for failing A or B I only have to bring up the Portuguese system, who nonetheless works incredibly thanks to the herculean effort put in place by everyone working there, despite all its failings and lack of investment, and people immediately acknowledge (thankfully) how lucky they are.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
BMJ blogs homepage

BMJ.com

Helping doctors make better decisions. Visit site



Creative Comms logo

Latest from BMJ.com

Latest from BMJ.com

Latest from BMJ.com podcasts

Latest from BMJ.com podcasts

Blogs linking here

Blogs linking here