You don't need to be signed in to read BMJ Blogs, but you can register here to receive updates about other BMJ products and services via our site.

Tom Nolan: Swine flu estimated to be 100 times more virulent than seasonal flu

3 Sep, 09 | by BMJ

PLOS Currents: Influenza is a journal with a difference. Mixing features of a journal with those of blogs and discussion forums it’s bound to ruffle some feathers. It describes itself as “a moderated collection for rapid and open sharing of useful new scientific data, analyses, and ideas.” Contributions are not peer reviewed other than for intelligibility, relevance and suitability. You can rate and comment on submissions and see how many other people have read them. Is this the future of research or a dangerous drop in standards? Either way, there are some interesting (and not-so interesting) things there. The most read knol (as the research is called, because it uses Google Knol’s community review function) is called “First estimation of direct H1N1pdm virulence.” It looks at incidence of ARDS due to swine flu in New Caledonia and Mauritius. The researchers suggest that infections resulting in ARDS can be used as a surrogate for the virulence of flu.

The direct lethality due to viral pneumonia gives probably the best estimate of influenza strains’ virulence, since it may vary from strain to strain, and is not due to the level of health development of a country. Furthermore, ARDS always leads to ICU, and is easy enough to diagnose and to report.
They estimate that the direct lethality of swine flu influenza is 1 in 10,000 infections, 100 times more than in seasonal influenza. But how much can we trust these results without peer review? In the comments that accompany the knol, the accuracy of this figure is challenged, but is that enough?

Vaccine update
Will the H1N1 flu vaccine be one dose or two? The Department of Health have said all along that they expect that two doses will be needed, but some manufacturers are claiming that only one will be necessary. Two of the six vaccines being reviewed this week by the Chinese health authorities for approval are single dose vaccines, their manufacturers saying that their evidence shows them to be effective with only one dose.
New guidance on vaccinations for pregnant women has been issued by the Centers for Disease Control.  It answers a variety of questions including one common one, that has been asked on this blog: ‘what safety studies have been done on the 2009 H1N1 influenza vaccine and have any been done in pregnant women?’

A number of clinical trials which test 2009 H1N1 influenza vaccine in healthy children and adults are underway. These studies are being conducted by the National Institutes of Allergies and Infectious Diseases (NIAID). Studies of 2009 H1N1 influenza vaccine in pregnant women are expected to begin in September.

Sneeze into your Elmo
President Obama and his administration have teamed up with Elmo from Sesame Street to tell the public how to prevent the spread of swine flu (apparently Miss Piggy was busy). Elmo is seen hugging US Secretary for Health and Human Services Cathleen Sebelius on one of a series of adverts. Sebelius wants you to cough and sneeze into your elbow. “Cover your sneezes with your sleeve, not your hands,”says Obama. Millions of Americans are now walking around with snot hanging from their sleeves and elbows, but at least they’re not spreading swine flu. How long will it be before we see Andy Burnham and Sir Liam Donaldson joining forces with Bob the Builder and Basil Brush?

Tom Nolan is a trainee GP in London.

By submitting your comment you agree to adhere to these terms and conditions
  • Azeem Majeed

    “They estimate that the direct lethality of swine flu influenza is 1 in 10,000 infections, 100 times more than in seasonal influenza.”

    This seems highly unlikely. This would make the lethality of seasonal flu 1 in 1,000,000 infections, which is an unfeasibly low rate.

  • http://www.conspirare.net notepad publishing

    H1N1 = Conspiracy?

    H1N1 notepad
    http://www.conspirare.net

    October 2009
    On October 1 2009, a former federal health minister dismisses as “crackpots and conspiracy theorists” those who would actively discourage Australians from having their swine flu vaccine’. October 2nd, the San Fransisco Chronicle publishes that ‘Everybody seems to be saying TRUST THE GOVERNMENT but it’s hard to trust the H1N1 vaccination campaign’ and on October 4rd, the Washington Post wonders ‘When the swine flu vaccine finally arrives this week, will Americans line up to get it?’ and CBS News writes about health care workers protesting the flu vaccine mandate. October 6th Foodconsumer publishes ‘Do NOT Let Your Child Get Flu Vaccine — 9 Reasons Why’ and writes that ‘modern medicine has no explanation for autism, despite its continued rise in prevalence. Yet autism is not reported among Amish children who go unvaccinated’. October 7th Healthnews writes that 72 percent are concerned about potential vaccine side effects and the Examiner writes that’ theorists believe that government may force people to take the vaccine’. October 8th Times&Transscript publishes that ‘a mercury-based preservative called thimerosal would be included as one of the substances in the H1N1 vaccine’, Medill Reports writes that Dr. Mayer Eisenstein is advising his patients to say no and is convinced that vaccines cause autism and the Los Angeles Times Blog publishes that media commentators Glenn Beck and Rush Limbaugh have apparently fallen prey to the loony websites of the anti-vaccine folks and that Beck would do “the exact opposite” of what the government recommended and attend a swine flu party. October 9th, The Christian Science Monitor publishes that ‘the vaccine is opposed, moreover, by naturopaths and even a well-known epidemiologist’ and that Glenn Beck from Fox News has devoted hours to ask ‘why the World Health Organization, “Big Pharma,” and the government are hyping a pandemic’?

    Read the full article with all media references @ http://www.conspirare.net

    notepad publishing (a non-profit news agency based in Switzerland)

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
BMJ blogs homepage

The BMJ

Helping doctors make better decisions. Visit site



Creative Comms logo

Latest from The BMJ

Latest from The BMJ

Latest from BMJ podcasts

Latest from BMJ podcasts

Blogs linking here

Blogs linking here