The human cost of being right. By David Díaz-Báez

A researcher spends years developing expertise, publishing papers, securing funding, and earning the recognition of colleagues. Eventually, that success leads to an invitation to direct a research group, an academic department, or a scientific institution. The appointment seems logical. After all, who better to lead science than someone who has demonstrated excellence in producing it?

But leading science and leading scientists are not quite the same thing.

Academic training prepares us to question hypotheses, interpret evidence, and defend our conclusions. Yet it rarely prepares us with the same intensity to manage disagreements, recognise frustrations, make difficult decisions, or understand how our actions affect others. We spend years learning how to become better researchers, often assuming that leadership will follow naturally from scientific achievement.

And sometimes, we mistake recognition for readiness.

Scientific expertise is essential in academic leadership, but it does not automatically provide the wisdom to exercise authority. A researcher may be exceptionally skilled at identifying methodological weaknesses and still struggle to listen to a colleague who challenges a decision. Someone capable of navigating scientific uncertainty may find it harder to acknowledge uncertainty in their own judgement as a leader.

This raises a question worth considering: Can we be scientifically right and humanly wrong?

Imagine a decision supported by strong evidence, with legitimate objectives and clear institutional benefits. Yet it is communicated without listening, concerns are dismissed, and disagreement is interpreted as resistance. The decision itself may be justified, but the way it is implemented can damage trust, discourage participation, and weaken the very team expected to carry it forward.

Being right is not the same as leading well.

Of course, leadership is not about pleasing everyone. Sometimes it requires saying no, defending difficult decisions, or accepting that disagreement will persist. But having evidence on our side does not exempt us from considering the people affected by our choices.

Perhaps this is where wisdom becomes as important as knowledge. Knowledge helps us understand what should be done; wisdom helps us consider how, when, and with whom. It requires recognising that expertise does not make our judgement infallible, and that listening to others does not diminish our authority.

The responsibility, however, is not entirely individual. Universities and research institutions often reward scientific productivity with leadership positions without equally considering the abilities needed to guide people. Publications, grants, and academic prestige are visible and measurable. The capacity to build trust, develop colleagues, or manage conflict is harder to capture, but no less important.

We also have a responsibility as researchers to question the assumption that professional success necessarily prepares us to lead. The skills that helped us build a scientific career may not be sufficient for the responsibilities that come with directing others.

In health sciences, this distinction matters beyond academia. How we lead influences how professionals are trained, how teams collaborate, and how knowledge is translated into practice. Scientific leadership shapes not only what institutions achieve, but also the conditions under which people work to achieve it.

Perhaps we should stop treating leadership as the natural reward for scientific excellence and start recognising it as a responsibility that requires its own preparation, reflection, and learning.

Science teaches us that being willing to be wrong is essential to producing better knowledge. Leadership may require something more: understanding that even when we are right, we still need wisdom to lead.

Author

David Díaz-Báez

David Díaz-Báez is a dentist and epidemiologist, Senior Researcher recognised by Colombia’s Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation, and Director of CePluS, the Interdisciplinary Health Research Center at Universidad El Bosque in Bogotá, Colombia. He also leads the Master’s Programme in Dental Sciences. His work focuses on clinical research, evidence-based healthcare, scientific leadership, and the translation of knowledge into health practice.

Declarations of Interest
I have read and understood the BMJ Group policy on declaration of interests and declare the following interests: none.

(Visited 1 times, 1 visits today)