You don't need to be signed in to read BMJ Group Blogs, but you can register here to receive updates about other BMJ Group products and services via our Group site.

Ask a Homeopath a Question…

29 May, 09 | by Iain Brassington

The Guardian has a feature in its “Ethical Living” feature called “You Ask, They Answer”.  This provides a forum in which readers can put questions to firms, people and so on.  This week, the subject was Neal’s Yard Remedies, purveyor of… um… “remedies” to the kind of people who go in for aromatherapy and homeopathy and the belief that natural is best because there are no CHEMICALS in nature. 

The grilling supplied by readers is impressive and heartening.  A lot of it is along the lines of “Why do you sell pointless crap and, in doing so, undermine the scientific method, spout bullshit, and potentially put people’s health in danger?”  (I’m simplifying a bit, but the gist’s about right.)

NYR’s response is… well, it isn’t.  They don’t seem to want to play any more, and won’t be answering.  Or maybe the answers have been provided but, in the best tradition of homeopathy, not in any detectable way.

4 Responses to “Ask a Homeopath a Question…”

  1. Homeopathy is an accepted scope of medicine specially for the chronic diseases.it works slowly but effectively through the illness.

  2. Nurse -
    We get a lot of comments on this site from Callcarenet (which, for the benefit of other readers, is whither “Nurse Triage”’s name links), and most of them are spam so get deleted. However, I’ve let this one through because - for once - it relates to the post to which it replies.

    All I’d ask, though, is that you provide some evidence. You know - proper, peer-reviewed stuff.

  3. Homeopathic medicines are usually much cheaper than comparable allopathic and ayurvedic drugs.

  4. I’ve allowed this comment through because I like a laugh.

    I deleted your link to an advert, though.

Leave a Reply

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
JME blog homepage

Journal of Medical Ethics

Analysis and discussion of developments in the medical ethics field. Visit site

Latest from JME

Latest from JME

Blogs linking here

Blogs linking here