You don't need to be signed in to read BMJ Group Blogs, but you can register here to receive updates about other BMJ Group products and services via our Group site.

Homeopathy: Healing the World (in very very very small doses)

7 Feb, 09 | by Iain Brassington

PZ Meyers has picked up a strange story: apparently, there’s an organisation called Homeopaths Without Borders – clearly picking up on MSF’s name – that intends to send crack teams of homeopaths to disaster areas.  Their site’s mainly in German at the moment – they promise updates – but here’s a taste of what they have to say about themselves so far:

It is our main aim to transfer homeopathy to those countries, [sic] where public health care and medical supply of [sic]the people is sub-standard, for whatever reasons. Homeopathy also proves very effective in healing physical and mental injury in situations of war or political crisis.

My understanding of homeopathy is limited – culled from reading Ben Goldacre and (for the other side) working on the same bar as a vegan hippie for 15 years – but I believe that one of its principles is that it is possible to get big improvements in a state of affairs from vanishingly small interventions.  Now, I’m sure I’m being unfair – in which case, please forgive me, and certainly don’t sue – but does that mean that HWB will do the most good by largely doing nothing in impoverished countries?  For once, that’s something about which homeopaths and real mainstream doctors ought to be able to agree.  Homeopathic interventions, both will admit, ought to be imperceptible.

For my part – one day I plan not to open my own homeopathic clinic.  I’m sure it’ll be wonderful.

By submitting your comment you agree to adhere to these terms and conditions
  • Ruth Wilkinson

    John Diamond’s “Snake Oil” is well worth a look by anyone interested in the value of alternative therapies. It’s only half a book, because he died before he could finish writing it, but the half that’s there is well researched, and well written. His view is similar to yours, Iain, that alternative therapies are often about doing nothing, insisting that patients stay away from mainstream medicine, whilst telling them that they’ll get better soon.

    Iain, I’m sure I’m not the only one looking forward to your non-clinic. Presumably there’ll be a non-waiting list as well…hang on a minute, maybe mainstream medicine can learn a thing or two!

  • Iain Brassington

    Ruth -
    Between my house and the office is a homeopathic clinic. The windows are frosted, but, from what I can tell, there’s nothing in there.

    It seems appropriate.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

Latest from JME

Latest from JME

Blogs linking here

Blogs linking here