You don't need to be signed in to read BMJ Blogs, but you can register here to receive updates about other BMJ products and services via our site.

Anita Jain: Ensuring no woman dies during childbirth in India

16 Jan, 14 | by BMJ

In conversation with my grandmother recently, I travelled nearly 60 years back in time to a village in Rajasthan as she recounted her near death experience during childbirth. Though lately prone to forgetting minor details, she surprised me with a vivid description of the events as they unfurled when she experienced excessive bleeding around the seventh month of her pregnancy. Nearly the whole village was driven into action that night. The local doctor astutely identified it to be an emergency requiring immediate referral to a higher centre. With no motorized vehicle available, a bullock cart was called into action and a bunch of people holding lanterns accompanied her to a clinic in the nearest town. It was a journey of four hours, that takes little under 30 minutes in a jeep today. A stillborn baby was delivered, and my grandmother, still critical, was taken to the nearest city hospital for urgent blood transfusion. With no blood bank, a matching donor was identified and finalized, but did not show up at the last minute. She pulled through however, and emerged, as she says, stronger from it.

I listened without interrupting, overwhelmed by what a woman may have to endure in the process of childbirth. For a moment, I was grateful for the focus of reproductive health programmes, and more recently the Millennium Development Goals, to reduce maternal mortality. For all one knows, there could have been no grandmother, and no me! Things that seem unimaginable to me in this day and age were real circumstances not too long ago. And possibly, in some regions, they still are.

Only last year, I had the opportunity to spend some time at SEWA Rural, a voluntary health organization offering services in a tribal belt in Gujarat. It was heartening to see the “108 ambulances” drive up to the hospital around-the-clock bringing women in labour, and other emergencies from remote areas. The evidence is still divided on promoting institutional deliveries as compared to delivering at home with the support of trained birth attendants. Yet, I believe, incentive schemes for institutional deliveries, and other means such as facilitating basic transport, represent a slow churn of a system that is evolving for the better.

As Gayatri Desai, a gynaecologist at SEWA Rural, explained the choices they and their patients have are at times still limited. A woman in a terminal condition may, for instance, prefer dying in the hospital, among caregivers, and in an environment she is familiar with and trusts, rather than traverse the complexity of a transfer to a higher centre if it offers little material hope. The context in which care is provided is therefore important, she emphasized, and may vary by region, local customs, and individuals.

It is this very context that the Association of Rural Surgeons of India puts forth in demanding that unbanked direct blood transfusion be made legal again for emergencies occurring in rural areas.  Even as licensed blood banks are essential, the fact is these have not become feasible in many parts of our country to date. Yogesh Jain, from Jan Swasthya Sahyog, puts it plainly, “Of course blood banks are desirable, but the best should not be the enemy of the good. In any case, the blood starved rural population needs some bread if there is no cake.”

No one size will fit all, and making available multiple solutions which are contextually relevant would make the largest dent.

Patient consent obtained.

Anita Jain is the India editor, BMJ.

By submitting your comment you agree to adhere to these terms and conditions
  • Dr Mohan Jangwal

    No doubt ,lot of improvement has been take place in the health care delivery system especially in the rural area, but still we have to go long way to achieve healthy mother healthy new born slogan , For this we should also put more efforts to address the reproductive behaviour as early marriage,male preference lead to more children, less participation of male in the reproductive health, social status of women in the society. For this more efforts are required to change the behaviour of the people to reduce the Maternal mortality in developing counteries,

  • akanksha mangla

    i think the demand for unbanked direct blood transfusion is completely unjustified, here we are not only considerate about ABO, Rh blood group but a lot of other antigens in human blood. many a times the patient with bleeding in pregnancy can be very well stabilised with intravenous fluids given judiciously. giving a direct blood transfusion will increase the transmission of infections, give rise to acute and severe blood transfusion reactions and increase the maternal morbidity and mortality. those clinicians working in rural settings should actually try to convince rural ladies to adopt contraception, temporary or permanent.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
BMJ blogs homepage

The BMJ

Helping doctors make better decisions. Visit site



Creative Comms logo

Latest from The BMJ

Latest from The BMJ

Latest from BMJ podcasts

Latest from BMJ podcasts

Blogs linking here

Blogs linking here